And in the process, he earned a standing ovation from every judge and sealed his status as a true contender for the Idol crown.
In his first finale performance, Jamal chose TEEKS’ emotionally rich ballad “First Time” a bold choice for a live audience of millions. Singing about the vulnerability of love, he didn’t rely on flashy runs or vocal theatrics. Instead, he let the emotion lead. Each lyric was laid down like silk and his navigated the song’s subtle shifts with the finesse of a seasoned artist; his control, phrasing and storytelling transformed the stage into a soul lounge proving that less is often more.
Jamal Roberts | First Time | Top 3 Perform | American Idol Season Finale 2025
As the final note faded, the judges immediately rose to their feet. Carrie Underwood called his voice “so comfortable and so good,” while Lionel Richie praised how Jamal effortlessly “navigated the story.” Luke Bryan, clearly awestruck, quipped, “Will you teach me how to be that smooth?” Online, fans echoed the sentiment, flooding social media with praise and calling the performance “the most polished of the night.”
But Jamal wasn’t done. Later in the evening, he shifted gears with a stunning rendition of “Heal” The transition from modern soul to timeless Motown showed his incredible range; not just vocally but emotionally; it felt like an artist taking his final bow reminding the world where he came from and who he’s become.
Jamal Roberts Performs His New Single “Heal” – American Idol 2025 Grand Finale
The second performance deepened the emotional arc of the night. Carrie Underwood described it as “fresh, new, and fun.” Bryan went further, calling Jamal “one of the most amazing people I’ve ever seen on this show,” while Lionel Richie simply said, “You are divinely guided.” The crowd responded with roaring applause; an affirmation that Jamal’s ability to reinvent classics is a rare gift.
Jamal’s rise hasn’t just been about TV moments. Offstage he continues to grow a loyal following on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook where he shares everything from acoustic rehearsals to life as a father of three. With his finale single “Heal” now streaming, he’s already charting a course beyond Idol; one grounded in authenticity and soul.
